Ruling allows city suit to move forward

Print Article

The City of Columbia Falls lawsuit against Badger Drilling Co. and its insurance company can move forward, Flathead County District Court Judge Heidi Ulbricht ruled late last month.

The case stems from an incident in August, 2011, when the city contracted Badger to drill a waterline under U.S. Highway 2 from a main near Super 1 Foods to the north that would ultimately serve the Timber Creek Village assisted living center.

Four years later, in February 2015, a sinkhole developed on the north side of the Highway. It was discovered that the water line had been drilled through a storm sewer main. The sewer main then collapsed, making a sinkhole.

The state, in turn, required the city pay for the repair, which it did, at a cost of more than $176,000.

The city, in turn, filed a claim against Badger to recoup the amount and Badger filed a claim with Cincinnati Insurance Companies, its insurer.

Cincinnati denied Badger’s claim and the city then brought suit, noting it had to make the repair in order to meet Department of Environmental Quality regulations for water lines.

Badger said it wasn’t at fault on several fronts, claiming that Montana’s Dig Law, re-empts common law, as Badger took the necessary precautions when it drilled the line.

Badger at the time it did the drilling claimed it wasn’t notified that the storm sewer was there by the state, even though it had gone through the proper notification procedures before it started drilling.

“The state did not ever locate or mark the storm drain at issue even though it was given ample time to do so,” Badger’s attorney Kristine Beal claimed previously.

Badger also claims it doesn’t owe the city, because the city volunteered to fix the problem.

But the city claimed the company should have known the drain was there, because there are manhole covers on the north side of the highway.

Ulbricht sided with Badger in part, but also sided with the city, which will allow the case to move forward.

“The court does not believe that the plain language of the Montana Dig Law precludes common law negligence actions brought by those who are not underground facility owners but are nonetheless damaged by an excavator’s failure to make an excavation in a reasonable and prudent manner,” Ulbricht ruled.

Print Article

Read More Local News

Many Glacier camp reopens to tents

July 16, 2018 at 4:18 pm | Hungry Horse News Glacier National Park has reopened the Many Glacier frontcountry campground to tents, after attempts to capture a rogue grizzly bear were unsuccessful. The Park closed the campground on June 30 afte...


Read More

Planning Board approves new apartment complex

July 13, 2018 at 9:29 am | Lake County Leader The Columbia Falls city-county planning board Tuesday approved plans to move forward with the construction 207-unit apartment complex on 13.83 acres at the end of Bill’s Lane. The vote was unanimous,...


Read More

Bowman Lake road will see construction closures starting July 17

July 12, 2018 at 10:42 am | Hungry Horse News Glacier National Park’s popular Bowman Lake Road will undergo construction this summer starting July 17. As a result. motorists can expect to see traffic restrictions. Construction will take place T...


Read More

Construction of new grandstands underway

July 11, 2018 at 7:16 am | Lake County Leader The framework is set and construction continues at the Sapa-Johnsrud Baseball Field in Columbia Falls as crews work to replace the grandstands that were lost in a fire more than two years ago. Since...


Read More

Contact Us

(406) 892-2151
PO BOX 189, 926 Nucleus Avenue
Columbia Falls, MT 59912

©2018 Hungry Horse News Terms of Use Privacy Policy